新明日报 Shin Min Daily News, and reporter Ong Yi Zhen (o[email protected]) in particular, I have somethings to say to you.
Theresa Tan of the Straits Times took pains to personally interview each family so that she could paint a well-rounded account of large families with graduate moms, and even including mentioning these famiies' religious convictions that spur them to making these pro-life, pro-family choices. Prime, Special Report, Saturday, dec 25 2010, Pg A18 More Grad Mums having big families
I recognise this is somewhat unusual for the usually very safely "non-religious" secular newspaper. It was a bold step she took but that's why I commend her for doing an honest job of it! She told it like it is.
Hubby and I were horrified to read a horribly edited version of Theresa Tan's original article in Straits Times. (I found out from Theresa that this was done without her knowledge.)
The day after it was published in the ST, Ms Ong of Shin Min Daily News (26dec 2010, pg 8一家养四个小孩,每月开销万五元) carelessly chose to lob off almost all religious context, shrink a whole page special report to a mere few paragraphs, worst of all, choosing depict these large families as financially struggling.
I was horrifed to read how my husband earns $8 OOO a month (not true, by the way), yet I seldom buy new dresses for myself and my children, likewise, wear old clothes, (because we can't afford to, as the context of her article implied!) This is a horrible horrible "translation" completely removed from the original context of what was spoken! See the original article for yourself. You will not get the idea that we are poor and struggling. But that was the implict slant of Ms Ong's crafty editing: large families have grave financial constraints.
The outrage!!! For shame! Not only is Ms Ong too lazy to do her own footwork, she irresponsibly character assassinates an entire demographic group! How does she have the cheek to put her name to that kind of work and publish it for the whole country to read? And I cannot help but wonder, too, how her employer can let such sloppy reporting work pass for print?
Oh Ms Ong, you do a great injustice for our Singapore baby drought crisis. MCYS ought to come knocking at your door for helping reinforce skeptics' perceptions that it is financial suicide to have (more) children. More work for them! You might have set them back another 10 years or so and couple 10 thousands of babies.
I got email, SMS, facebook responses of how encouraged people were for what we are doing as a family after the ST article. However, if one only read Ms Ong's article, one would come to the perception that one needs to be prepared for a life of misery and serious belt tightening if they were to have many children in Singapore.
I only hope that people would dig around for the truth. This blog will be testament of all the love and sound family/ parenting philosohies we hold to, despite some struggles. It is only sad that damage has been done.
Recent Comments